Corporate & Commercial

Ferbrache & Farrell LLP’s corporate department offers full service corporate, banking and commercial cover and is able to advise on all aspects of Guernsey corporate and commercial law, including banking and finance, regulatory, investment funds, asset management and listings on The International Stock Exchange (TISE).

Latest Insight
23 July 2026
Press Release
Ferbrache & Farrell (F&F) and Aztec Group (Aztec) assisted their long-standing mutual client, Lakestar, a leading European venture capital investment adviser, on the successful closing of the…
Dispute Resolution

The Dispute Resolution department at Ferbrache & Farrell LLP has vast experience of local and international litigation and dispute resolution generally, gained from acting in complex local and international high-value disputes, both in Guernsey and throughout the world.

Latest Insight
18 November 2026
Article
Further to a recent successful application for summary judgment, the Royal Court has refused leave for the unsuccessful Applicant to appeal this decision. In light…
Property

The Guernsey property department is dedicated to providing tailored solutions that meet and exceed clients’ expectations. In addition, the property department provides support to colleagues in the corporate and dispute resolution departments on real estate-related technical points of law.

Latest Insight
17 November 2026
News
Guernsey’s planning and development framework is set for significant changes following the approval of two new pieces of legislation: the Land Planning and Development (Plans)…
UK Real Estate

We are delighted to help in relation to providing legal advice for real estate in England and Wales. We listen. We learn what your needs are. We proactively respond. Whether it’s personal or commercial property, we always provide sound and pragmatic advice, adding value to the transaction.

Latest Insight
20 May 2026
News
The Land Registry has today released the UK House Price Index for March 2026, showing that average UK house prices fell by 0.4% between February…
Private Client

Our services for private client matters include the drafting of realty and personalty wills, acting as professional executors, and assisting foreign lawyers who have requirements in this jurisdiction.

Latest Insight
20 May 2026
News
The Land Registry has today released the UK House Price Index for March 2026, showing that average UK house prices fell by 0.4% between February…

Further to a recent successful application for summary judgment, the Royal Court has refused leave for the unsuccessful Applicant to appeal this decision.

In light of this decision, this article considers the circumstances in which an unsuccessful party may choose to appeal an unfavourable decision, and the steps that they would need to take in order to do so.

Leave to Appeal

The starting position under section 15 of the Court of Appeal (Guernsey) Law, 1961 is that an unsuccessful party has a right of appeal against a final judgment or order without first obtaining leave. Leave is only required in certain defined categories. In particular, an unsuccessful party must obtain the leave of the presiding judge of the court which made the order (or the leave of the Court of Appeal) in order to appeal:

  • Any order made with the consent of the parties or as to costs; and
  • Any interlocutory order or interlocutory judgment.

Even where an order or judgment is interlocutory, leave is not required where the liberty of the subject or the custody of a child is concerned; in the case of an order in a matrimonial cause, or a judgment or order in an admiralty action determining liability; or in such other cases, prescribed by rules of court, as are of the nature of final decisions.

A small number of decisions cannot be appealed at all. No appeal lies from a decision which, under any enactment, is to be final; from a final order for the dissolution or nullity of marriage made where the party concerned had the opportunity to appeal the provisional order on which it was founded but did not do so; or from a judgment or order of the Royal Court sitting as a Full Court where no point of law is involved.

Where leave is required, it may be sought either from the presiding judge of the court whose decision is to be appealed, or from the Court of Appeal. An application to the Court of Appeal for leave to appeal an interlocutory order or judgment is made to a single judge of the Court of Appeal. The single judge’s decision on the application is final; however, the single judge may at any stage refer the application to the full Court of Appeal for decision.

The Test for Leave

The matter of whether or not to grant leave was discussed in detail in ITG Limited v Glenalla Properties Limited [2022] GCA 091. In this case, it was argued by the Applicant that “if the prospects of success are more than merely fanciful, leave must be allowed” however this position was rejected by the Court of Appeal. Instead, it was decided that the Court should not grant leave unless it is satisfied that (i) the appeal has a real prospect of success or (ii) even though the case has no real prospect of success, there is an issue which, in the public interest, should be examined by the Court of Appeal.

In practice, this means that the Court will only grant leave for appeal in circumstances whereby there was an error in fact or law (i.e. where existing evidence was misinterpreted or unavailable at the time of trial, or that the law was misapplied to these facts) or where the appeal is unlikely to succeed, but the subject matter of the case is such that it would be in the public interest to hear it (i.e. to expand Guernsey-specific jurisprudence in a specific area).

Susan Cotteril v The Medical Specialist Group & Mr Ranjan Vhadra

In this matter, summary judgment was awarded on the basis that there was clear and compelling agreed medical evidence on multiple core areas that manifestly undermined Ms Cotteril’s claim. She then opted to appeal this judgment on the following grounds:

  • Misapplication of the summary judgment test;
  • Premature determination of disputed factual and expert issues;
  • Failure to consider amendments correcting factual matters; and
  • Reliance on hypothetical strike-out reasoning without full determination.

When considering the appeal, the Judge evaluated the evidence in its totality, but gave particular weight to the joint experts’ report. It was reiterated that the medical evidence (which had been agreed by both the Applicant and the Respondent’s experts) did nothing but undermine her case, including the supplementary report provided by her expert. None of the other grounds were found to have any merit and as such, leave to appeal was refused on the grounds that any appeal would not have a real prospect of success. Further, as regards to part (ii) of the test, the Judge did not feel as though there were any public interest reasons why an appeal should be allowed despite the lack of prospects of success.

After being unsuccessful in her application for leave to appeal, Ms Cotteril elected to appeal this decision, such application being heard before the Court of Appeal. Ultimately, the Court of Appeal agreed with the Royal Court Judge and refused to give leave to appeal. The Bailiff sitting as a single judge of the Court of Appeal took the view that the application should be refused. He also considered whether the application should be referred to the plenary court of the Court of Appeal (ie the full court) but, ultimately, decided that it would not be appropriate as there was no prospect of the application succeeding.