Few events carry greater risk for a business professional than being called to attend an interview with a regulator, investigator, law enforcement agency or even their own employer. The consequences of what is said, and how it is said, can shape the course of an investigation, disciplinary process or regulatory enquiry long before any formal decision is reached. The title of this article is not an endorsement of silence or non-cooperation. Rather, it reflects a principle that applies to almost every interview: accuracy is more important than speculation.
Whether the interview arises from a regulatory enquiry, a suspicious activity report, a criminal investigation, an internal investigation or an HR process, there is often a natural temptation to keep talking. Many people feel compelled to answer immediately, fill every pause and provide a response to every question. Whilst understandable, that instinct can create significant difficulties.
In our experience, problems rarely arise because a client answers a question honestly. More often, difficulties arise when a witness moves beyond their actual recollection in a genuine effort to be helpful. What begins as an estimate, inference or reconstructed memory can later be tested against documents, emails and contemporaneous records and presented as an inconsistency.
For that reason, interviewees should never be reluctant to acknowledge the limits of their knowledge. If you do not know, do not guess. If you do not remember, say so. If you need to review documents before answering, explain that. A witness who candidly acknowledges the limits of their recollection is often far more persuasive than one who feels obliged to have an immediate answer to every question.
Preparation therefore matters. Our role is to ensure clients are properly supported and equipped to provide accurate evidence. Just as importantly, we help clients understand that they do not need to venture beyond the limits of their own knowledge. In appropriate cases, a carefully prepared written statement can be invaluable. Prepared in a calmer and less pressured environment, it provides an opportunity to reflect properly on the documents, chronology and facts, reducing the risk of error and allowing for a more measured response. Equally, where a question requires further consideration, it may be entirely appropriate to provide a considered written response following the interview.
Sometimes, you say it best….
To discuss matters raised in this article, please contact the F&F LLP Dispute Resolution Team – Richard Harrington, Robin Gist, Rebekah Johnston, Aimee Brown, or Kirsty Hart.